After spending way too much time trying to decide which butterfly to highlight for this month’s Butterfly Bucket List post, I finally settled on the Gray Hairstreak (Strymon melinus). This little butterfly is common to the entire state of Texas and was particularly abundant in my garden this Spring. Well, I certainly thought I’d settled. Upon closer inspection of my photos I found that I actually had taken pictures of two separate butterflies — the Gray Hairstreak and the Soapberry Hairstreak (Phaeostrymon alcestis).
These butterflies are both members of the Lycaenidae family and Theclinae subfamily of butterflies. When they’re out and about in the garden, flitting from plant to plant, it’s just about impossible to tell them apart. To help highlight the differences between the two I’ve pictured them side by side in the photos below.
Noticeable Differences Apparent In These Images
- The Gray Hairstreak has one long tail on each hindwing — the Soapberry Hairstreak has two long tails on each hindwing.
- The orange color on the underside of the Gray Hairsteak is mostly centered on two spots on the edge of the hindwing, while on the Soapberry Hairstreak it continues for most of the entire edge of both wings.
- The bands on the underside of the Soapberry Hairstreak are much more jagged than those of the Gray Hairstreak, forming what looks almost like a large M shape in one area.
- The Soapberry Hairstreak has a long white dash further toward the middle of the undersides of both wings, while the Gray Hairstreak does not.
- The Gray Hairstreak appears gray in color, as its name implies, while the Soapberry Hairstreak is more of a brownish-gray color.
I’m sure there are other differences, but these are the ones that stood out as I compared the two butterflies. Of course, depending on what part of the country they’re found in, there might be regional differences, as is the case with many butterfly species.
Gray Hairstreak Butterfly Facts
- Gray Hairstreaks range in size from about 7/8 to 1-3/8 inches (2.2 to 3.5 cm). They’re small butterflies!
- Adult butterflies feed on the nectar of many different flowers, including Blood Flower (Asclepias curassavica), Common Milkweed (Asclepias syriaca), Cow Vetch (Vicia cracca), Dogbane (Apocynum), Mint (Mentha), Queen Anne’s Lace (Ammi majus), Goldenrod (Solidago), Tick Trefoil (Desmodium) and White Sweet Clover (Melilotus alba). The Gray Hairstreaks in the photos above are feeding on Butterfly Flower (Asclepias tuberosa) and winter onions.
- Caterpillar hosts include plants such as Mallow (Malvaceae) and Buckwheat (Eriogonum), among others.
Soapberry Hairstreak Butterfly Facts
- Soapberry Hairstreaks range in size from about 1 to 1-1/2 inches (2.5 to 3.8 cm).
- Adult butterflies feed on the nectar of a variety of flowers, much the same as the Gray Hairstreak. The Soapberry Hairstreaks pictured above are feeding on Plains Coreopsis (Coreopsis tinctoria).
- The caterpillar host is the Western Soapberry (Sapindus saponaria var. drummondii).
While the Gray Hairstreak is widely seen throughout the entire United States, the normal range of the Soapberry Hairstreak is from Arizona through Texas and northward into Oklahoma and Kansas.
Below is a view of the upperside of the Gray Hairstreak, which I was really lucky to get considering the constant movement of these butterflies. They never seem to sit still long enough to get a good shot of them! All of the photos in this post were taken during the latter part of May and early June of this year.
Thanks for visiting my Butterfly Bucket List post for the fourth Sunday of June. If you’d like to take part please do so! While the meme posting day is the 4th Sunday of each month, feel free to post your sightings any time within the following week. Just put a link to your post in the comment section of this post. I look forward to seeing the butterflies, moths and caterpillars that have paid visits to your garden during the past month!
[…] to The Transmutational Gardener for hosting the Butterfly Bucket List, a new wildlife blogging event all about butterflies I am […]
LikeLike
Thanks for joining in! I visited your wonderful post. Lovely butterfly!
LikeLike
Great photos! Hairstreaks never do stay still. Your description is really clear, too. I can see the difference now. Isn’t that smoky grey colour pretty! Thanks for mentioning the host plants — that’s really helpful info.
LikeLike
Thanks! It seemed that every time I got close to one, it fluttered a few feet away and I’d have to give chase. My husband at least found it amusing. Now every time I come back into the house with my camera he asks “Catch any butterflies?”
LikeLike
Well, this is just fascinating and I’m now wondering if I have mis-identified. Duh–like that’s never happened before!! What a wonderful idea to devote a day for butterfly musings–good for you! Your photos are beautiful and instructive. Thank you.
I’d love to add your to the meme calendar? Okay?
LikeLike
Please do! Thanks. I’m glad you enjoyed the post and hope you’ll join in too.
LikeLiked by 1 person
interesting ID of the butterflies and beautiful photos showing the details, I find butterflies very hard to photograph, Frances
LikeLike
Thanks. Chasing the butterflies is part of my exercise routine…
LikeLiked by 1 person
I bet if I had the patience to go back (and I so do not) I’d see I’d confused the two hairstreaks at some point, that is if soapberries get west of Austin much. What a great side by side comparison, requiring some stellar photos to use as examples. These tiny butterflies are always dashing around – they seem to be drawn to a patch of oregano regularly here. And it is great to have host plant information with such clear identifying information all in one place. I’m a fan!
LikeLiked by 1 person
The sightings map on the Butterflies and Moths of North America site shows sightings in and around the Austin area. I’m glad you enjoyed the post! Feel free to join in.
LikeLike
Lovely looking butterfly, photographed very well..
Amanda xx
LikeLike
Thanks, glad you enjoyed!
LikeLike
Such beautiful photos – the gray hairstreak is stunning against the orange flower
LikeLike
It’s amazing how intricately colored the small butterflies and moths can be once you get a close-up view!
LikeLiked by 1 person
What gorgeous butterflies and fantastic photos.
LikeLike
Thanks! It was a joy to take the photos.
LikeLike
I agree with above-fantastic photos! What a soft butterfly. I love the muted tones + I was looking at that picture before I read the next section of your post and wondered- What is that? Neat captures
LikeLike
These little butterflies just flit around from one plant to the next. I really hadn’t looked at them very closely until I took the photos. It’s amazing what’s out there!
LikeLike
Lovely post, I would love to join in next month, your photographs are wonderful, it’s a patient person who captures butterflies!
LikeLike
I think the butterflies have to be a little patient, too!
LikeLiked by 1 person
A most enjoyable, and interesting, post and wonderful pictures. It’s always good to see butterflies, which I’ve always felt have an almost magical presence. xx
LikeLike
They add an extra dimension to the garden.
LikeLike
[…] who writes the lovely ‘Transmutational Garden‘ blog is hosting a new meme – Butterfly Bucket List, posting on the 4th Sunday of every […]
LikeLiked by 1 person
Anna, I got my act together and wrote a little post to join in with you this month, lovely idea for a meme.
https://gardeningjules.wordpress.com/2015/06/29/butterfly-bucket-list-on-sharpenhoe-clappers/
LikeLiked by 1 person
I am a bit late but linking in none-the-less as we finally had one butterfly resting long enough for me to get a picture…only a handful flew through recently but most have stayed away due to the rain. Love the hairstreak but I don’t think I have seen one in my garden…loads of clover here which is a host plant for them so maybe some day!
http://gardenseyeview.com/2015/07/06/gardens-eye-journal-july-2015/
LikeLike
Never too late! Thanks for joining in with your great post. That butterfly is a real beauty.
LikeLike